top of page
Search

Chubb vs Allianz Premier: Which Insurer Protects Australia’s Luxury Homes Better in 2025?

Australia’s prestige property market continues to surge, especially in suburbs like Vaucluse, Point Piper, Mosman and Bellevue Hill in Sydney; Toorak, Brighton, Balwyn and Hawthorn in Melbourne; Cottesloe, Dalkeith, City Beach and Swanbourne in Perth; and Ascot, Hamilton and Teneriffe in Brisbane. These are suburbs where architectural homes, bespoke interiors and ultra-high rebuild costs dominate.

As homeowners in these blue-chip suburbs face rising insurance premiums and more volatile weather conditions, the debate over Chubb vs Allianz Premier becomes increasingly relevant. This blog breaks down how the two insurers perform across coverage, claims, risk assessment and suitability for high-value Australian homes.




A prestige luxury residence in Toorak, Melbourne — the exact type of high-value architectural home requiring specialist insurers like Chubb for comprehensive protection in Australia’s top-tier suburbs.
A prestige luxury residence in Toorak, Melbourne — the exact type of high-value architectural home requiring specialist insurers like Chubb for comprehensive protection in Australia’s top-tier suburbs.


Why These Two Insurers Dominate the Prestige Market

Chubb and Allianz Premier both specialise in homes valued well above standard market levels — particularly those built with imported stone, custom joinery, engineered glass, steel structures, heritage façades or integrated smart-home systems.


They service nearly identical geographic markets across Australia:

  • Sydney Eastern Suburbs: Vaucluse, Dover Heights, Bellevue Hill, Rose Bay

  • Lower North Shore: Mosman, Cremorne Point, Kirribilli

  • Melbourne Prestige Belt: Toorak, Brighton, Kew, Hawthorn, Canterbury

  • Perth Coastal: Dalkeith, Cottesloe, City Beach, Swanbourne

  • Brisbane Premium: Ascot, Hamilton, New Farm


These areas represent the highest rebuild cost zones in the country, making insurer choice hugely important.


Coverage Comparison: Where Chubb and Allianz Differ


1. Extended Replacement Cover

One of the biggest differentiators:

  • Chubb: Known for offering extended rebuild coverage, often exceeding the declared sum insured if costs blow out.

  • Allianz Premier: Offers high cover limits but may not provide the same extended replacement flexibility.


Relevance: Essential in suburbs with escalating labour and material costs like Toorak and Vaucluse.


2. Valuables & Art Collections


Homes in places like Brighton, Mosman and Cottesloe often feature expensive art, wine, watches, and high-end furniture.


  • Chubb: Typically provides higher sub-limits for art, jewellery and collections.

  • Allianz Premier: Good coverage but may require additional specified items above certain thresholds.


3. Building Specifications & Risk Appetite

For complex homes:

  • Chubb: Strong appetite for bespoke architecture and custom materials.

  • Allianz Premier: Strong but can be more conservative on extremely coastal or high-storm risk sites.


Example: Ocean-facing homes in Dover Heights or City Beach may favour Chubb’s inspection-based approach.


Claims Experience & Support


This is where many luxury homeowners develop strong opinions.


Chubb

Renowned for white-glove handling, fast response times and dedicated claims managers. Particularly relevant in disaster-prone regions like:

  • Brisbane (storm season)

  • Perth coastal suburbs (wind exposure)


Allianz Premier

Also strong, with significant resources, but the experience can vary depending on claim type and assessor availability.


Risk Mitigation Services


Both insurers conduct home assessments in high-value suburbs.


  • Chubb: Often praised for proactive measures — water leak sensors, fire safety recommendations, maintenance oversight.

  • Allianz: Provides detailed reports but tends to be more traditional in approach.


Homeowners with older architecture in Kew, Hawthorn or Sydney’s Upper North Shore may benefit more from Chubb’s intervention style.


Performance Across Australia’s Elite Suburbs


Sydney


Vaucluse, Point Piper, MosmanChubb generally suits ocean- and harbour-front homes; Allianz Premier is strong inland and with heritage builds.


Melbourne


Toorak, Canterbury, Brighton, BalwynChubb is preferred for high-spec rebuilds; Allianz Premier performs well on established prestige homes with stable risk profiles.


Perth


Cottesloe, Dalkeith, Swanbourne, City BeachChubb handles coastal weather volatility effectively; Allianz may price aggressively inland.


Brisbane


Ascot, Hamilton, New FarmBoth insurers work well here, with Chubb slightly better during high-storm seasons.


Side-by-Side Snapshot (2025)

Feature

Chubb

Allianz Premier

Extended Replacement

✔ Often higher

✔ High, but varies

Art & Valuables Cover

✔ Strongest

✔ Good

Claims Handling

✔ Industry leading

✔ Solid

Coastal Appetite

✔ Higher

✔ Moderate

Heritage Homes

✔ Strong

✔ Very strong

Pricing

💲💲

💲–💲💲

Which One Is Better for 2025?

There is no single “winner” — but patterns are clear:


Choose Chubb if:

✔ You own a coastal, modern architectural home

✔ You have art, jewellery or luxury collections

✔ You want extended replacement protection

✔ Your home is in Vaucluse, Toorak, Dalkeith, Brighton or Cottesloe


Choose Allianz Premier if:

✔ Your home is heritage, federation or character-style

✔ You prefer a slightly sharper premium

✔ Your property is inland or lower exposure

✔ You live in Canterbury, Hawthorn, Hunters Hill, Balwyn


Final Thoughts

Chubb and Allianz Premier are the two heavyweights of Australia’s luxury home insurance landscape in 2025. The best choice ultimately depends on where you live, the build type, your valuables, and your exposure to coastal or storm-related risks.


In suburbs where rebuild costs are rising fastest — Sydney’s Eastern Suburbs, Melbourne’s Golden Mile and Perth’s premium coastline — the differences between these insurers can have real financial impact.





 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page